Study Report

Basic Info
Reference |
Biederman J, 200818937309
|
Citation |
Biederman J., Kim J. W., Doyle A. E., Mick E., Fagerness J., Smoller J. W. and Faraone S. V. (2008) "Sexually dimorphic effects of four genes (COMT, SLC6A2, MAOA, SLC6A4) in genetic associations of ADHD: a preliminary study." Am J Med Genet B Neuropsychiatr Genet, 147B(8): 1511-8.
|
Study Design |
case-control and family-based |
Study Type |
Candidate-gene association study |
Sample Size |
474 ADHD affected offspring |
Predominant Ethnicity |
Caucasian |
Population |
USA |
Gender |
308 males and 166 females |
Age Group |
Children/Adolescents and Adults
:
2-39 years
|

Detail Info
Summary |
They have investigated four ADHD candidate genes (COMT, SLC6A2, MAOA, SLC6A4) for which there is evidence of sexually dimorphic effects. Past neurobiological and genetic studies suggest that COMT, and SLC6A4 variants may have a greater influence on males and that SLC6A2, and MAOA variants may have a greater influence on females. Their results indicate that genetic associations are stronger when stratified by sex and in the same direction as the previous neurobiological studies indicate: associations were stronger in males for COMT, SLC6A4 and stronger in females for SLC6A2, MAOA. Moreover, they found a statistically significant gender effect in the case of COMT when they pooled their work with a prior study. In conclusion, they have found some evidence suggesting that the genetic association for these genes with ADHD may be influenced by the sex of the affected individual. |
Total Sample |
The final data set used in this study consisted of 474 ADHD affected offspring. Of those, 266 were probands and the remaining 208 were siblings who had ADHD. The age for the ADHD patients at the time of assessment ranged from 2 to 39 years. Three hundred sixty-one patients were children and 83 patients were adults at the time of assessment. |
Sample Collection |
The current analyses are derived from family studies of ADHD and bipolar disorder being conducted at the Massachusetts General Hospital. Additional sibling pairs with ADHD were ascertained from a family study of adults with ADHD. |
Diagnosis Description |
Initial affection status for individuals and their relatives was based on DSM-IIIR criteria; however lifetime DSM-IV criteria was asked at follow up interviews. For subjects of additional sibling pairs with ADHD, affection status was based on DSM-IV criteria for ADHD. |
Technique |
The genotyping for SNPs was performed using a multiple base extension reaction with allele discrimination by MassArray mass spectrometry system (BrUnited Kingdomer-Sequenom) as previously described [Sklar et al., 2002]. |
Analysis Method |
The TDTPHASE program of the UNPHASED set [Dudbridge, 2003] was used for TDT analysis of transmission to each sex. They also tested whether there was a statistically significant difference between the transmissions to males vs. transmissions to females (gender effect) for each gene using a standard chi-square test with 1 degree of freedom. They converted each Chi-square value to z-scores, using a formula to examine the overall effect of the COMT Val158Met polymorphism in two independent samples including our families and another case¨Ccontrol study [Qian et al., 2003] |
Result Description |
Their results indicate that genetic associations are stronger when stratified by sex and in the same direction as the previous neurobiological studies indicate: associations were stronger in males for COMT, SLC6A4 and stronger in females for SLC6A2, MAOA. Moreover, the found a statistically significant gender effect in the case of COMT (P=0.007) when they pooled their work with a prior study. |

SNPs reported by this study (count: 4)
SNP |
Allele Change |
Risk Allele |
Statistical Values |
Author Comments |
Result of Statistical Analysis |
rs2066713 |
|
|
TDT P-value=0.254 for all; TDT P-value=0.151 for transmission to male offspring; TDT P-value=1 for transmission to female offspring; TDT P-value=0.398, X2=0.71 for male versus female transmissions |
they observed no evidence of association either in the full ......
they observed no evidence of association either in the full sample or when stratified by gender
More...
|
Non-significant
|
rs3027399 |
|
|
TDT P-value=0.093 for all; TDT P-value=0.757 for transmission to male offspring; TDT P-value=0.021, OR=2.5 for transmission to female offspring; TDT P-value=0.111, X2=2.54 for male versus female transmissions |
TDT analysis in the full sample was not significant and show......
TDT analysis in the full sample was not significant and showed a nominally significant effect for females but not for males
More...
|
Significant
|
rs3785143 |
|
|
TDT P-value=0.02 for all; TDT P-value=0.37 for transmission to male offspring; TDT P-value=0.006, OR=2.11 for transmission to female offspring; TDT P-value=0.101, X2=2.68 for male versus female transmissions |
TDT analysis in the full sample showed nominally significant......
TDT analysis in the full sample showed nominally significant association and the T allele of rs3785143 displayed a stronger effect in females than in males
More...
|
Significant
|
rs4680 |
|
|
TDT P-value=0.023 for all; TDT P-value=0.003, OR=1.42 for transmission to male offspring; TDT P-value=0.936 for transmission to female offspring; TDT P-value=0.071, X2=3.27 for male versus female transmissions. P-value=0.007, Z=2.69 in pooled analysis of this study and a case-control study [Qian et al., 2003] |
TDT analysis in the full sample showed nominally significant......
TDT analysis in the full sample showed nominally significant association and they observed overtransmission of the Met (A) allele to male offspring but not to female offspring; the pooled result showed a statistically significant gender effect for Val158Met in ADHD
More...
|
Significant
|

Genes reported by this study (count: 4)
Gene |
Statistical Values/Author Comments |
Result of Statistical Analysis |
SLC6A2 |
rs3785143 showed nominally significant association in the fu......
rs3785143 showed nominally significant association in the full sample and the T allele displayed a stronger effect in females than in males
More...
|
Significant
|
MAOA |
rs3027399 showed a nominally significant effect for females ......
rs3027399 showed a nominally significant effect for females but not for males
More...
|
Significant
|
COMT |
rs4680 showed overtransmission of the Met (A) allele to male......
rs4680 showed overtransmission of the Met (A) allele to male offspring but not to female offspring; the pooled result showed a statistically significant gender effect for Val158Met in ADHD
More...
|
Significant
|
SLC6A4 |
no SNP showed evidence of association
no SNP showed evidence of association
|
Non-significant
|